Quick answer: The Silhouette Cameo 5 is the better all-around cutter for sticker making. It has 24x more cutting force (5,000g vs 210g), a full 12-inch cutting width, and faster speed (400mm/s). At $329.99, it handles everything from delicate sticker paper to thick vinyl and magnet sheets.
Choose the Silhouette Portrait 3 ($199.99) if you work in a small space, make planner-sized or smaller stickers, need portability for craft fairs, or want to save $130. It handles standard sticker paper and vinyl perfectly well, just not thick or specialty materials.
Specs Comparison: Cameo 5 vs Portrait 3
| Feature | Cameo 5 | Portrait 3 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $329.99 | $199.99 | Portrait 3 |
| Cutting Force | 5,000g | 210g | Cameo 5 |
| Cutting Speed | 400mm/s | Standard | Cameo 5 |
| Max Cutting Width | 12" | 8" | Cameo 5 |
| Roll Feeder | Optional add-on | Included | Portrait 3 |
| Software | Silhouette Studio (Free) | Silhouette Studio (Free) | Tie |
| Carriage | Dual (2 tools) | Single | Cameo 5 |
| Weight | 9.5 lbs | 4.8 lbs | Portrait 3 |
| Dimensions | 22.4" x 7.1" x 6.3" | 16.5" x 5.7" x 5.4" | Portrait 3 |
| Thick Materials | Excellent | Limited | Cameo 5 |
| Auto Tool Detection | Yes | Yes | Tie |
| Touchscreen | Yes | Yes | Tie |
The biggest differences are in cutting force (5,000g vs 210g), width (12" vs 8"), and physical size. Both use the same free Silhouette Studio software, so there's no software advantage to either machine.
Cutting Performance: Where the Gap Shows
Cutting Force: 5,000g vs 210g
This is the most significant difference between the two machines. The Cameo 5 has nearly 24 times the cutting force of the Portrait 3. In practical terms:
- Standard sticker paper: Both cut cleanly with no difference
- Printable vinyl: Both cut cleanly with no difference
- Holographic sticker paper: Both handle well
- Thick vinyl (2mm+): Cameo 5 cuts in one pass; Portrait 3 struggles or cannot cut
- Magnet sheets: Cameo 5 cuts cleanly; Portrait 3 not recommended
- Chipboard: Cameo 5 handles thin sheets; Portrait 3 cannot
- Multi-layer stacking: Cameo 5 cuts 2+ sheets at once; Portrait 3 limited to one thin layer
Cutting Width: 12" vs 8"
The 4-inch width difference matters more than you might think. A 12-inch width lets you cut a full letter-size sheet of stickers in one pass. With the 8-inch Portrait 3, you need to trim standard paper or use smaller sheets. For common sticker sizes:
- 2-inch round stickers: Cameo 5 fits 6 across; Portrait 3 fits 4 across
- 3x3 inch stickers: Cameo 5 fits 4 across; Portrait 3 fits 2 across
- Full-page sticker sheets: Cameo 5 handles full width; Portrait 3 requires trimming
Cutting Speed
The Cameo 5 cuts at 400mm/s, which is noticeably faster than the Portrait 3. For a sheet of 12 die-cut stickers:
- Cameo 5: ~90 seconds
- Portrait 3: ~2.5 minutes
For hobbyists, this difference is minor. For small businesses producing large volumes, the Cameo 5 saves meaningful time over a workweek.
Size, Portability & Workspace
This is where the Portrait 3 shines. At 4.8 lbs and roughly 16.5 inches wide, the Portrait 3 is easy to move, store, and transport. The Cameo 5 weighs 9.5 lbs and spans over 22 inches wide, making it a more permanent desk fixture.
When Size Matters
- Small apartment or shared desk: Portrait 3 fits easily on a shelf or in a drawer
- Craft fairs and events: Portrait 3 is light enough to carry in a tote bag
- Classroom use: Portrait 3 is easier for students to handle and store
- Permanent workspace: Either machine works; size is not a concern
The Portrait 3 also includes a built-in roll feeder, which the Cameo 5 requires as an optional add-on. If you cut long continuous lengths of vinyl or specialty media, the Portrait 3's included roll feeder is a convenient advantage.
Software & Value
Both machines use Silhouette Studio, which is free to download and use. There's no subscription required for either machine, and the core sticker-making features are identical. Paid upgrades ($49.99-$99.99 one-time) add features like SVG import but are optional.
Cost Comparison
| Cost Item | Cameo 5 | Portrait 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Machine Price | $329.99 | $199.99 |
| Software | Free | Free |
| Cutting Mats (2 pack) | $20 | $17 |
| Extra Blades (per year) | $15 | $15 |
| Roll Feeder | $49.99 (optional) | Included |
| Initial Cost | $349.99 | $216.99 |
The Portrait 3 saves $130 upfront. Over time, the cost of consumables (mats, blades) is nearly identical. The only add-on cost difference is the roll feeder, which is included with the Portrait 3 but optional for the Cameo 5.
Who Should Buy Which?
Choose Cameo 5 If:
- You run a small sticker business and need production speed
- You cut thick materials like magnet sheets, chipboard, or heavy vinyl
- You want full 12-inch width for large sticker sheets
- You need dual-tool capability (cut and score in one pass)
- You have a dedicated workspace and don't need portability
Choose Portrait 3 If:
- You make small stickers, planner decals, or card-making projects
- You have limited desk space or need to store the machine between uses
- You want portability for craft fairs, classes, or events
- You're on a tighter budget and want to save $130
- You only cut standard sticker paper and vinyl (no thick materials)
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, if you need full 12-inch width or cut thick materials regularly. The Cameo 5 costs $130 more ($329.99 vs $199.99) but delivers 24x more cutting force (5,000g vs 210g), faster speed (400mm/s), and a 12-inch cutting width. For small stickers, planner decals, and card-making, the Portrait 3 is sufficient. For business use or large stickers, the Cameo 5 pays for itself quickly.
Not all of them. The Portrait 3 has 210g of cutting force compared to the Cameo 5's 5,000g. Both handle sticker paper, printable vinyl, and cardstock easily. However, the Portrait 3 struggles with thick vinyl, magnet sheets, chipboard, and multi-layer cuts that the Cameo 5 handles without issue. If you only cut standard sticker materials, the Portrait 3 works fine.
The Portrait 3 is significantly more compact and lighter than the Cameo 5. It takes up roughly half the desk space and is easy to store in a drawer or shelf. The Portrait 3 also includes a built-in roll feeder for continuous cuts. If you have limited workspace or need portability for craft fairs and events, the Portrait 3 is the better choice.