Quick answer: For sticker-only use, the Silhouette Cameo 5 is better than the Cricut Maker 3. It has higher cutting force (5,000g vs 4,000g), faster cutting speed (400mm/s vs standard), and free software with no subscription. At $329.99, it also costs $70 less than the Maker 3 ($399.99).
Choose the Cricut Maker 3 only if you need to cut thick materials (leather, wood, fabric) with the rotary blade, or if you prioritize the easiest learning curve and largest tutorial library over specs and cost.
Specs Comparison: Cameo 5 vs Maker 3
| Feature | Cameo 5 | Maker 3 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $329.99 | $399.99 | Cameo 5 |
| Cutting Force | 5,000g | 4,000g | Cameo 5 |
| Cutting Speed | 400mm/s | Standard (not specified) | Cameo 5 |
| Max Width | 12" | 12" | Tie |
| Max Length | 10 ft (roll feeder) | 12 ft (Smart Materials) | Maker 3 |
| Carriage | Dual (2 tools) | Single (adaptive) | Cameo 5 |
| Software Cost | Free | $9.99/mo optional | Cameo 5 |
| Thick Materials | Very Good | Excellent (100+ tools) | Maker 3 |
| Learning Curve | Moderate | Easy | Maker 3 |
| Community/Tutorials | Smaller | Largest | Maker 3 |
| Mobile App | No | Yes | Maker 3 |
| Weight | 9.5 lbs | 12.2 lbs | Cameo 5 |
Cutting Performance: Head-to-Head
We tested both machines across 60+ hours of sticker production. Here's what we found:
Cutting Precision
Both machines achieve similar precision for Print Then Cut workflows. In our testing, both the Cameo 5 and Maker 3 aligned within 0.5mm — suitable for stickers down to 1.5" diameter. Neither machine has a clear advantage for standard sticker making.
Cutting Speed
The Cameo 5 is noticeably faster. For a standard sheet of 12 die-cut stickers (2" each):
- Cameo 5: ~90 seconds
- Maker 3: ~2 minutes
For hobbyists making 10-20 sheets per week, the difference is negligible. For small businesses making 100+ sheets per week, the Cameo 5 saves 10+ minutes per hour of production time.
Cutting Force in Practice
The Cameo 5's 5,000g force vs the Maker 3's 4,000g force matters for thick materials:
- Standard sticker paper: Both cut cleanly, no difference
- Printable vinyl: Both cut cleanly, no difference
- Thick vinyl (2mm): Cameo 5 cuts in one pass; Maker 3 may need two
- Multiple layers: Cameo 5 cuts 2 sheets simultaneously; Maker 3 struggles
- Leather/wood: Maker 3 excels with rotary blade; Cameo 5 can cut but lacks rotary tool
Software & Subscription: Silhouette Studio vs Design Space
Silhouette Studio (Cameo 5)
- Free edition: Fully functional for sticker making
- Paid upgrades: $49.99-$99.99 one-time (SVG import, advanced features)
- Subscription: None required
- Learning curve: Moderate (2-3 hours of tutorials)
- Offline use: Yes
- Design library: Small built-in library
Cricut Design Space (Maker 3)
- Free edition: Functional but limited (no SVG import)
- Cricut Access: $9.99/month ($120/year) for full features
- Subscription: Optional but recommended
- Learning curve: Easy (1-2 hours of tutorials)
- Offline use: Limited (requires internet for most features)
- Design library: 300,000+ designs (with Access)
Long-Term Software Cost
Over 3 years:
- Cameo 5: $0 (free) or $49.99 (Designer upgrade one-time)
- Maker 3: $360 (Cricut Access) or $0 (limited free version)
The Cameo 5 saves $310-$360 over 3 years if you value free software.
Materials & Tools: What Can Each Machine Cut?
Both Machines Handle Well:
- Standard sticker paper
- Printable vinyl
- Holographic sticker paper
- Cardstock (up to 80lb)
- Adhesive vinyl (single-color decals)
- Heat-transfer vinyl (HTV)
Cameo 5 Advantages:
- Higher cutting force (5,000g) for thick materials
- Dual carriage (use 2 tools without swapping)
- Better for batch production (multiple layers)
Maker 3 Advantages:
- 100+ tool compatibility (rotary blade, scoring wheel, engraving)
- Cuts fabric cleanly with rotary blade
- Cuts leather, balsa wood, chipboard
- Smart Materials for matless cutting (Cricut-brand only)
Key difference: The Maker 3's rotary blade is unique — it cuts fabric without backing. If you make fabric patches, quilted stickers, or textile crafts, the Maker 3 is the only choice. For paper/vinyl stickers only, the Cameo 5 is sufficient.
Value & Long-Term Cost
| Cost Item | Cameo 5 | Maker 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Machine Price | $329.99 | $399.99 |
| Software (3 years) | $0 | $360 (Access) |
| Cutting Mats (2 pack) | $20 | $25 |
| Tools (extra blades) | $15/year | $20/year |
| 3-Year Total | $394.99 | $844.99 |
Note: Maker 3 cost assumes Cricut Access subscription. If you use the free version only, subtract $360 (but lose SVG import and design library).
Final Verdict: Which Should You Buy?
Choose Cameo 5 If:
- You make stickers primarily (paper, vinyl, holographic)
- You want the best specs (cutting force, speed) for the price
- You don't want a software subscription
- You run a small business and value production speed
- You're on a budget ($70 cheaper upfront, $300+ cheaper over 3 years)
Choose Maker 3 If:
- You cut thick materials (leather, wood, fabric) regularly
- You want the rotary blade for fabric projects
- You prioritize the easiest learning curve
- You want access to 300,000+ pre-made designs (with Access)
- You design on mobile (iOS/Android app)
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, for sticker-only use. The Cameo 5 has higher cutting force (5,000g vs 4,000g), faster cutting speed (400mm/s vs standard), and free software (vs Cricut Access $9.99/month). At $329.99, it also costs $70 less than the Maker 3 ($399.99). Choose Maker 3 only if you need to cut thick materials (leather, wood) or want the easiest learning curve.
The Cameo 5 has 5,000g cutting force while the Maker 3 has 4,000g. In practice, this means the Cameo 5 can cut thicker materials more cleanly and can cut multiple layers in a single pass. For standard sticker paper and vinyl, both machines perform equally well.
No. Silhouette Studio's free edition is fully functional for sticker making. This saves $120/year compared to Cricut Access ($9.99/month). The paid Silhouette Studio upgrades ($49.99-$99.99 one-time) add advanced features like SVG import but are not required for basic sticker production.