The brand isn't the variable — the ink system is. An Epson EcoTank prints a full-coverage sticker sheet for around $0.01-$0.03 in ink. A Canon PIXMA cartridge model prints the identical sheet for $0.10-$0.15. At 500 sheets a month that is a $600-$900 per year difference, and Canon's own tank line (MegaTank G-series) lands right alongside EcoTank.
Choose Epson if you want the cheapest per-sheet cost, borderless Letter printing and a piezo head that isn't a consumable. Choose Canon if you print photographic sticker art and want the smoother gradients from a 5-ink setup, or you already own a PIXMA and print fewer than ~50 sheets a month.
Why Brand Matters Less Than the Ink System
Both companies sell the same two architectures, and the price gap between architectures is an order of magnitude larger than the gap between brands:
- Cartridge systems (Canon PIXMA TS/TR, Epson Expression) — cheap printer, expensive ink. The printer is priced to be sold at a loss and recovered on consumables.
- Bulk-ink tank systems (Canon MegaTank G-series, Epson EcoTank) — expensive printer, near-worthless ink. A $12-15 bottle of Epson ink replaces dozens of cartridges.
| Model | System | Street Price | Quoted Color Cost/Page | Real Cost Per Sticker Sheet |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Epson EcoTank ET-2800 | Tank (4-color) | ~$199 | ~$0.005 | $0.01 - $0.03 |
| Canon PIXMA G3270 (MegaTank) | Tank (4-color) | ~$250 | ~$0.004 | $0.01 - $0.03 |
| Canon PIXMA TS6420a | Cartridge (5-color) | ~$80 | ~$0.08 | $0.10 - $0.15 |
| HP ENVY 6055 | Cartridge | ~$70 | ~$0.07 | $0.05 - $0.10 |
The Cost-Per-Sheet Math Nobody Shows You
Advertised yields are measured at ISO coverage — roughly 5% of the page covered in ink, mostly text. Sticker sheets with solid color fills run 30-50% coverage. Multiply accordingly:
- Quoted at $0.005/page (tank) → about 6-10x at sticker coverage = $0.03 worst case per sheet.
- Quoted at $0.08/page (cartridge) → $0.10-$0.15 per sheet, and the tri-color cartridge runs out mid-project, which is the real cost: a half-dead color cartridge stops production entirely.
- Cartridge printers also throw away the cartridge at 100-400 pages whether or not the ink is used up, so real cost is worse than the per-page arithmetic suggests.
Color Quality: Where They Genuinely Differ
- Ink count. Epson's ET-2800 is 4-color. Several Canon PIXMA cartridge models are 5-color, adding a dedicated photo black. On photographs and smooth gradients, that photo black is visible — less dithering in shadow areas. On flat-color vector artwork (the overwhelming majority of sticker designs), you will not see it.
- Resolution numbers are marketing. 5760 x 1440 vs 4800 x 1200 tells you nothing useful; both are far beyond what a sticker needs at normal viewing distance.
- Head technology. Epson uses MicroPiezo heads that are part of the printer and sized to last its life. Canon uses FINE thermal heads, which are consumables you may replace. For tank models, Canon's replacement head is a real long-term cost line; for Epson, head failure usually means a service call.
- Dye ink, both brands. Neither is a pigment printer at this price, so both need laminate for outdoor life. The lamination guide applies identically whichever you buy.
- Grayscale washes. Canon cartridges have a documented tendency to shift pale greys warm; Epson shifts cool. Matters for pale watercolor-style sticker art — test one sheet before committing.
Media Handling and Borderless
| Practical sticker feature | Epson EcoTank ET-2800 | Canon PIXMA TS6420a |
|---|---|---|
| Rear feed for thick media | Yes | Yes (rear tray) |
| Borderless up to Letter 8.5x11 | Yes | No — caps around 8x10 |
| Thick sticker paper (up to ~300 gsm) | Handles well via rear feed | Handles, more prone to skew |
| Print Then Cut marks | Solid black, reliable | Solid black, reliable |
| Driver media options | Granular (per-media profiles) | Good, fewer profiles |
| Ink refill during a job | Top-fill bottles, seconds | Cartridge swap, interrupts job |
| Speed, color draft | Slow (~5 ppm quality) | Slow (~5-7 ppm) |
Borderless at Letter is the sleeper difference. If your layouts run edge to edge on a full 8.5" x 11" sheet — common for sticker packs sold as sheets — a printer that caps borderless at 8x10 forces a white margin or a trim step. The exact settings for the Epson side are in our ET-2800 sticker settings guide.
12-Month Total Cost of Ownership
| Line item | Epson ET-2800 | Canon TS6420a | Canon G3270 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Printer | $199 | $80 | $250 |
| Ink, 1,500 sheets/yr | $23 - $45 | $150 - $225 | $18 - $40 |
| Cartridge/head replacements | $0 | included above | $0 - $60 |
| Wasted ink on empty-color swaps | ~$0 | $30 - $80 | ~$0 |
| Year-one total | $222 - $244 | $260 - $385 | $268 - $350 |
| Year two onward (ink only) | $23 - $45 | $180 - $305 | $18 - $100 |
Assumes 500 letter sticker sheets per month at 30-50% ink coverage, 12 sheets per page, and street prices at time of writing. Ranges reflect bottle/cartridge pricing differences between brands and sales cycles.
By month twelve the cheap Canon has already cost more than the Epson, and from there it costs six to ten times as much every month. The tank Canon is a real competitor to the EcoTank — the difference is driver feel and borderless support, not money.
Verdict: Which to Buy
- Sticker business, 100+ sheets a month: Epson EcoTank ET-2800. Cheapest ink in this comparison, borderless Letter, no consumable head. Pair it with a 12" cutter — see the small business printer + cutter ranking.
- Hobby, under 50 sheets a month: the Canon you already own. A cartridge PIXMA is genuinely fine at low volume; the math only turns against you as volume climbs.
- Photographic sticker art: a 5-color Canon PIXMA — but buy it as a MegaTank G-series so the ink doesn't eat your margin.
- High volume, wide sheets: neither. Both cap at 8.5". Look at the 13" high-volume pick in our printer roundup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Epson — but the deciding factor is tank versus cartridge, not brand. An EcoTank ET-2800 prints a full-coverage sticker sheet for about $0.01-$0.03. A Canon PIXMA TS-series cartridge printer prints the same sheet for $0.10-$0.15. Canon's MegaTank G-series lands in the same range as EcoTank, so a Canon tank printer is not meaningfully more expensive to run.
Manufacturer yields are measured at ISO coverage, roughly 5% of the page. A sticker sheet with solid color fills runs 30-50% coverage, so real ink cost is 6 to 10 times the quoted cost per page. That's why a cartridge printer advertised at a few cents a page can cost 15 cents per sheet of stickers, and why tank systems win so decisively on this specific job.
On photographic artwork, Canon's 5-ink models add a dedicated photo black that smooths gradients in skin tones and skies. On flat-color and illustrated sticker art — most sticker work — the difference disappears. Media type set to a glossy photo profile affects your result far more than the brand does.
Either, provided it prints crisp solid black registration marks and can print at exactly 100% scale. Epson has one practical edge: the ET-2800 supports borderless Letter, so designs can bleed to the sheet edge, while several budget PIXMA models cap borderless at 8x10 and force a white margin. After that, cut accuracy comes down to calibration.